Provincial
by-elections will be held in two Quebec electoral districts today to
replace two Quebec City-area Members of the National Assembly (MNA).
The ridings being vacated are Chauveau, north of Quebec City and
Jean-Talon, located in the city's west end. Chauveau was vacated in
April when its MNA, Gerard Deltell of the centre-right Coalition
Avenir Quebec (CAQ) announced he would be running for the federal
Conservatives in this fall's federal election. Jean-Talon was vacated
when its MNA, Liberal Yves Bolduc resigned in February following
controversy when he, in his capacity as the province's education
minister defended a policy which allowed a school administrator in
the city to strip search a 15 year old student.
While neither riding
is held by the sovereigntist Parti Quebecois (PQ), it will be the
first test for that party since its election of media mogul
Pierre-Karl Peladeau as leader in May. Despite some considering his
candidacy and media presence in the last provincial election as
having cost the party the election, the PQ has seen a boost in the
polls since Peladeau's election as leader. The PQ is now up eight or
nine points since last year's general election, while the Liberals
are down about 10 points, and the CAQ is down about three points.
Both Chauveau and Jean-Talon are safe ridings for their respective
parties, but a two-party Liberal to PQ swing of 10 points in
Jean-Talon might put that riding into play.
Chauveau
Geography
Like many provincial ridings in Quebec, Chauveau is not named for its
geography, rather it is named for a person, Pierre-Joseph-Olivier
Chauveau, the first Premier of Quebec who also represented the region
during his time in office. Applying a single geographic name to this
riding would be challenging, as it covers a number of different
communities north of Quebec City.
Most of the population of the riding lives in a number of suburban
communities within the city limits of Quebec City. It contains most
of the borough of La Haute-Saint-Charles (including the
neighbourhoods of Loretteville, Saint-Emile and Lac-Saint-Charles) as
well as the neighbourhood of Note-Dame-des-Laurentides in the borough
of Charlesbourg. The riding also contains the Wendake Indian Reserve,
which is completely surrounded by La Haute-Saint-Charles borough.
From the Quebec City suburbs in the south, the riding runs northwest
into the Quebec hinterland, containing the municipalities of
Lac-Beauport, Lac-Delage, Stoneham-et-Tewkesbury and the uninhabited
Lac-Croche unorganized area, which makes up the northern two-thirds
of the riding's geographic territory.
Demographics
Chauveau is overwhelmingly Francophone, with 98.2% of its inhabitants
having French as their mother tongue. Just 1.5% of the riding is
Anglophone. The riding is also overwhelmingly White, with 97% of the
riding having no visible minority nor are Aboriginal. 1.5% of the
riding is Aboriginal, the second largest racial group in the riding.
Ethnically, most of the riding is of French Canadian stock, while
there are a handful of people of Irish descent. 87% of the riding is
Catholic, while most of the rest of the population (10%) has no
religion. The riding is more wealthy than the provincial average; the
median income is $35,000 (opposed to the provincial median of
$28,000) while the average income is $39,000 (compared to the
provincial average of $36,000).
History
Being located in suburban Quebec City, Chauveau is much more conservative leaning than the rest of the province. Right of centre parties have held the riding continuously since 2007. While the riding supported the Yes side in the 1995 referendum by nine points, the riding's conservative leanings have allowed the Liberals to win here before the emergence of more right leaning parties in the last decade. Since 2007 though, it has been a safe ADQ/CAQ seat. The riding was one of only seven to vote for the ADQ in the 2008 provincial election.
MNAs:
Quebec-Comte (1867-1966)
1) P.-J.-O. Chauveau, Cons. (1867-1873)
2) Pierre Garneau, Cons. (1873-1878)
3) D.A. Ross, Liberal (1878-1881)
*) Pierre Garneau, Cons. (1881-1886), 2nd time
4) T.C. Casgrain, Cons. (1886-1890)
5) Chas. Fitzpatric, Liberal (1890-1896)
6) Nemese Garneau, Liberal (1897-1901)
7) C.F. Delage, Liberal (1901-1916)
8) Aurele Leclerc, Liberal (1916-1923)
9) Ludger Bastien, Cons. (1924-1927)
10) J.-E. Bedard, Liberal (1927-1935)
11) F. Byrne, Liberal (1935-1936)
12) Adolphe Marcoux, U.N. (1936-1939)
13) F.-X. Bouchard, Liberal (1939-1944)
14) Rene Chaloult, Independent (1944-1952)
15) J.-J. Bedard, Liberal (1952-1956)
16) Emilien Rochette, U.N. (1956-1960)
*) J.-J. Bedard, Liberal (1960-1966), 2nd time
Chauveau (1966-present)
17) F.-E. Mathieu, U.N. (1966-1970)
18) Andre Harvey, Liberal (1970-1973)
19) Bernard Lachapelle, Liberal (1973-1976)
20) Louis O'Neill, P.Q. (1976-1981)
21) R. Brouillet, P.Q. (1981-1985)
22) Remy Poulin, Liberal (1985-1994)
*) R. Brouillet, P.Q. (1994-2003), 2nd time
23) Ms. Sarah Perreault, Liberal (2003-2007)
24) Gilles Taillon, A.D.Q. (2007-2008)
25) Gerard Deltell, A.D.Q./C.A.Q. (2008-2015)
Political
geography
In last year's provincial election, Deltell won the seat easily, by
nearly 10,000 votes, winning 52% of the vote to the Liberal's 30%. If
we just look at the election day votes, Deltell won every single
polling division in the riding. In fact, he won a majority of the
election day votes in every neighbourhood of the riding, winning as
much as 62% in Saint-Emile, while his worst community was
Lac-Beauport, where he still won 53% of the vote. The advance and
special votes in the riding made the total election results closer.
Deltell only won 42% of those votes, to the Liberal's 39%. The
strongest community for the Liberals was the Wendake Indian Reserve,
where they won 35% of the vote. The strongest area for the PQ was
Lac-Delage where they won 20% of the vote. Lac-Dalage was also the
best community for the left wing Quebec solidaire, where they won 8%.
The CAQ won every single poll in the riding in 2012 as well, when
Deltell won by an even larger margin of 12,500 votes over the Liberal
candidate. In 2008, when Deltell only won by 2600 votes, the Liberals
were able to win a few more polls, such as those in Wendake and in
Lac-Beaport. The PQ also won a few polls.
 |
| 2014 election results in Chauveau by community |
Federally, Chauveau covers parts three ridings: Louis-Saint-Laurent,
Charlesbourg—Haute-Saint-Charles and Portneuf—Jacques-Cartier.
Due to the area being fairly homogenous, most of Chauveau votes the
same way in each election. In 2011, most of the area went NDP, with a
splattering of Conservative polls in suburban areas like
Loretteville, which is in the more Tory-friendly riding of
Louis-Saint-Laurent. In 2006 and 2008, most of the area voted
Conservative, except the area in Portneuf—Jacques-Cartier which
backed libertarian leaning Independent Andre Arthur. In 2004, most of
Chauveau backed the Bloc Quebecois.
Outlook
The CAQ, Liberals and the PQ are all running journalists as their
candidates. The CAQ is running Jocelyne Cazin a former television
host on TVA, who has been criticized for having been parachuted in by
the CAQ to run in this safe seat. The Liberal candidate, Veronyque
Tremblay actually lives in the riding, and is known in the area for
working at a popular local radio station. The PQ candidate is
Sebastien Couture, who is the chief reporter of a monthly newspaper
which serves the northern rural parts of this district. Quebec
solidaire is running educator Marjolaine Bouchard. The Conservatives,
Option nationale and two other minor parties are also running
candidates.
Despite not living in the riding, the clear front runner has to be
Jocelyne Cazin of the CAQ. It does not get much safer for the
centre-right CAQ than in Chauveau. I expect them to take a hit in the
polls, but should get no lower than the 43% the ADQ (the CAQ's
predecessor) won here in 2008. The Liberal vote could take a hit here
as well, if the province-wide polls are to be believed. The PQ will
likely see a large boost, but they are only starting from the 12%
they won in 2014. I expect both parties will be in the low to mid 20%
range. If the PQ is lucky, they might even finish second.
Jean-Talon
Geography
Further south is the riding of Jean-Talon, named for the 17th
century colonial administrator of New France. The riding, with its
present boundaries is located in the west end of the city, in the
Sainte-Foy—Sillery—Cap-Rouge borough. The riding contains the
neighbourhoods of Cite-Universitaire (surrounding Laval University),
Plateau, Saint-Louis, Sillery and part of Pointe-de-Sainte-Foy. The
riding is much more urban than Chauveau, as it just covers the
inner-suburbs immediately west of Quebec City's downtown.
Demographics
This part of Quebec City was once the English speaking part of the city, or at least where much of the English population lived. Today it remains the most English part of the region, however only 3.1% of the population is Anglophone, while, 94.1% is Francophone. There is also a comparatively large percentage of Arabic speakers and Spanish speakers in the district. Both languages are the mother tongues of 2% of the population. 91% of the riding is White, while Blacks, Arabs and Latin Americans all account for about 2% of the population respectively. While most of the riding has French Canadian origins, there is also a significant population with Irish ancestry. Nearly three quarters (73%) of the riding is Catholic, while there is also a small Muslim population (3%). 16% of the riding is non religious. The riding is more wealthy than the province as a whole, however is has a higher income inequality. The average income is $42,000 while the median income is $30,000.
History
While the riding of Jean-Talon has existed since 1966, the area that Jean-Talon now covers has been historically divided between both Jean-Talon and Louis-Hebert. The 2011 redistribution brought in near-equal parts from both ridings to create Jean-Talon with its current boundaries. Historically, Jean-Talon was centred on the community of Sillery, while Louis-Hebert was centred on Sainte-Foy. Louis-Hebert still exists, but the 2011 redistribution moved the riding westward, where it now contains Quebec City's western suburbs.
Jean-Talon's political history is noted for being a Liberal bastion.
Jean-Talon has never elected an MNA from any party except for the
Liberals. Counting the predecessor riding of Quebec-Ouest, the riding
has voted Liberal continuously since 1952. The PQ has had more
success in Louis-Hebert during the time it mostly covered what is
today Jean-Talon. It had PQ representation from 1976 to 1982 and from
1994 to 2002.
Despite the riding's overwhelming Liberal history, they PLQ does not
win this riding by huge landslides in every election. In 2014, Bolduc
won the seat comfortably with a 7700 vote margin, but did not win a
majority of the vote, getting just 45%. In 2012, the race was much
closer, with Bolduc winning by 3500 votes and winning just 37% of the
vote. The last time the Liberals won a majority of the vote here was
in a 2008 by-election, where Bolduc won 58% of the vote. The race in
this district has always been between the Liberals and the PQ.
Neither the ADQ nor the CAQ have been able to place second here,
although they have come close to finishing second in the last two
elections.
MNAs:
Quebec-Ouest (1867-1966)
* Jn. Hearn, Cons. (1867-1877)
* R. Alleyn, Cons. (1877-1878)
* A.H. Murphy, Liberal (1878-1881)
* Felix Carbray, Cons. (1881-1886)
* Owen Murphy, Liberal (1886-1892)
* Felix Carbray, Cons. (1892-1900) 2nd time
* J.G. Hearn, Liberal (1900-1904)
* J.C. Kaine, Liberal (1904-1916)
* M. Madden, Liberal (1916-1927)
* J.I. Power, Liberal (1927-1935)
* Chas. Delagrave, Liberal (1935-1944)
* Wilfrid Samson, Liberal (1944-1948)
* J.-A. Saucier, U.N. (1948-1952)
* Jules Savard, Liberal (1952-1956)
* J.-P. Galipeault, Liberal (1956-1960)
* Jean Lesage, Liberal (1960-1966)
Louis-Hebert (1966-2012)
* Jean Lesage, Liberal (1966-1970), continued
* Claude Castonguay, Liberal (1970-1973)
* Gaston Desjardins, Liberal (1973-1976)
* Claude Morin, P.Q. (1976-1982)
* Rejean Doyon, Liberal (1982-1994)
* Paul Begin, P.Q. (1994-2002); Independent (2002-2003)
* S. Hamad, Liberal (2003-2012)
Jean-Talon (1966-present)
* Henri Beaupre, Liberal (1966-1970)
* R. Garneau, Liberal (1970-1979)
* J.C. Rivest, Liberal (1979-1985)
* G. Remillard, Liberal (1985-1994)
* Mrs. M.F. Delisle, Liberal (1994-2007)
* P. Couillard, Liberal (2007-2008)
* Yves Bolduc, Liberal (2008-2015)
Political
geography
In the 2014 election, Bolduc won nearly every poll in the riding. The PQ did win five polls (and tied another), four of which were located near the eastern border of the riding, close to the PQ-held riding of Taschereau. The CAQ won 12 polls, nine of which were located in the more suburban western part of the riding, west of Autoroute Henri-IV. The Liberals were strongest in Sillery, where they won 43% of election day votes. Their worst neighbourhood was Cite-Universitaire, where they won 38% of the votes. Interestingly, the best neighbourhood for the PQ was also Sillery (23%), while the best neighbourhood for the CAQ was the Plateau (27%). For Quebec solidaire, their best neighbourhood was Cite-Universitaire, thanks to the student population. Election day votes varied greatly from the advance and special votes, where the Liberals won a majority of the votes. In 2012, both the CAQ and PQ won many more polling divisions. While the Liberals won across the riding, the PQ saw most of its support east of Autoroute Henri-IV, while the CAQ saw most of its support west of Autoroute Henri-IV.
 |
| 2014 election results in Jean-Talon by neighbourhood |
In Federal elections, Jean-Talon is located in the riding of
Louis-Hebert. In 2011, the NDP swept the area, winning nearly every
poll. In 2008, the Bloc won most of the riding. In 2006, when the
Tories won Louis-Hebert by just 231 votes, Jean-Talon mostly
supported the Bloc. In 2004, the area was divided between the Bloc
and the Liberals, with the former mostly winning in the Sainte-Foy
parts of the riding, and the latter winning in the Sillery part.
Outlook
Considering Jean-Talon's political history, it is unlikely that the Liberals will lose this seat. However, the by-election will make for a good test to determine the popularity of Pierre-Karl Peladeau as leader of the PQ. The Liberals for their part have a strong candidate in Sebastien Proulx, the former ADQ MNA for Trois-Rivieres from 2007 to 2008. The PQ is running businessman (Vice president of De Marque Inc.) Clement Laberge against him. The CAQ candidate will be businessman Alain Fecteau (President of International Geo Alliance) while Quebec solidaire will be running businesswoman (President of Plan B Entertainment) Amelie Boisvert. The leader of Option nationale Sol Zanetti is also running, as are the Conservatives, the Greens, and three minor parties.
Polls close in both ridings at 8pm.
