Showing posts with label PEI. Show all posts
Showing posts with label PEI. Show all posts

Friday, April 24, 2015

Meanwhile in PEI: 2015 election projection #1

While the Alberta election campaign continues to excite politicos, there is another province in the country holding an election: Prince Edward Island. Islanders head to the polls on May 4th, the day before the Alberta election. And unlike Alberta, most believe the election in P.E.I. is a foregone conclusion. However, with just one poll released during the campaign so far, we are still in the dark as to what exactly is happening there.


Presently, the Prince Edward Island Liberal Party is enjoying a great deal of support in the province. It has been in power since 2007, winning landslide majorities in both the 2007 and 2011 elections under the leadership of Robert Ghiz. Last November, Ghiz unexpectedly announced he'd be resigning as Premier, effective in February. Despite the large lead in the polls the Liberals have enjoyed, just one candidate ran to replace Ghiz. University of Prince Edward Island president Wade MacLauchlan threw his hat in the ring, and no one, not even a sitting MLA, ended up running against him, due to his wide support from caucus and from the federal Liberals' three Members of Parliament. MacLauchlan became Premier on February 23rd, and also became the first openly gay man to become a Premier in Canada.

Following MacLauchlan's ascension in February, the Liberals immediately received a large boost in the polls. A Corporate Research Associates (CRA) poll conducted at the time indicated that the Liberals were at 58%, the highest they have been at since the 2011 election, where they won 51% of the popular vote and 22 seats. The opposition Tories were at 26% in the poll, a 14-point drop since 2011, when they won five seats. The seat-less NDP polled at 12%, an increase nine points since 2011, but a significant drop from where they were polling at in the 2012-2013 period, where they peaked at 32%. The Greens were at 4% in the poll, which is what they won in 2011 (ahead of the NDP).

The only pollreleased during the campaign so far was conducted by Abingdon Research. Released Tuesday, it showed a drop in Liberal support (43%), and an increase in NDP (18%) and Green (12%) support. The Tories were at 27% in the poll, a one-point increase since the CRA poll in February. It was this poll that formed the basis of today's projection.

There were no regional breakdowns in the poll, so I just extrapolated the poll's numbers across the whole province, based on the a proportional swing from the 2011 election. The NDP is running a full slate of 27 candidates for the first time since 2000, so for the ridings where they did not run in 2011, I projected how it would have voted based on how the NDP did in those areas in the federal election. I did the same for the Green Party, which also did not run a full slate in 2011 (and is running in all but two seats this election). Additionally, I boosted the support of the four party leaders in their ridings, as none of them led their respective parties in 2011. Additionally, I removed some support for parties in ridings where their leaders ran in 2011, based on what result I believe an average candidate would have received there.



The result of my projection is that the Liberals would gain two seats at the expense of the Tories. Despite their strong polling numbers, neither the Greens nor the NDP would win any seats, according to my model. A huge caveat to remember is that elections in PEI are very localized, due to the small size of the ridings, and the province's political traditions. A proportional swing model alone cannot reflect the local races on the ground.
While the Liberals are polling below their 2011 levels, the drop in Tory support has my model showing them gaining both Souris-Elmira and Tignish-Palmer Road. Despite the fact that the Liberals are in landslide territory (which is typical for PEI elections), they would only win a majority of votes in five ridings, including York-Oyster Bed, the riding where Wade MacLauchlan is running in.

My model shows the Tories reduced to just three seats: Georgetown-St. Peters, Stratford-Kinlock and Morell-Mermaid. All three of those seats are traditionally safe Tory seats. The Liberals have only won one of those seats (Stratford-Kinlock in 2007) since their creations in 1996. New Tory leader Rob Lantz is looking to enter the legislature by running in Charlottetown-Brighton, but my model shows him in 4th! I admit this is probably too low for the former city councillor.

For the Greens, they are concentrating all of their resources in trying to elect their leader Peter Bevan-Baker in the riding of Kellys Cross-Cumberland. This sometimes successful strategy helped get federal Green leader Elizabeth May elected in her riding, as well as get New Brunswick Green leader David Coon elected in his riding in last year's provincial election there. This may prove successful; my model has him in a close race against the Liberals.

For the NDP, they have not won a seat on the island since 1996, when then-leader Herb Dickieson won the Prince County seat of West Point-Bloomfield. Their new leader Michael Redmond chose to run in Kings County's Montague-Kilmuir riding, a district that the NDP has not run in since 2003 (where they won just 30 votes). The NDP's best shot at a seat is in the capital, where my model has them in a close race in Charlottetown-Lewis Point, behind the Liberals.

Here are the projected results for each riding. Ridings are shaded by how they voted in 2011:



Tuesday, October 4, 2011

Prince Edward Island 2011 election - results

Unofficial final results map


The results are in from Prince Edward Island, and the Liberals, under Premier Robert Ghiz have won another majority government. The party won 22 of the island's 27 seats, down two from the 2007 election. The Tories won five seats, up two. The Liberals received 51% of the vote, the Tories 40%, the Greens won 4%, the NDP 3% and the new Island party 1%. The popular vote nearly mirrored the 2007 election, with the Liberals down 2%, the Tories down 1%, while the Greens and NDP were both up 1%.

Party
Leader
Popular vote
%
Seats
Liberal
Robert Ghiz
38304
51.4
22
Progressive Conservative
Olive Crane
29948
40.2
5
Green
Sharon Labchuk
3239
4.4
0
N.D.P.
James Rodd
2355
3.2
0
Island Party
Billy Cann
682
0.9
0
Independents
-
15
0
0

The Tories performed better than the most recent poll had them had, getting 4% more, while the Liberals were down 2% from that poll. This allowed the party to win many two more seats than I had projected.

Where I went wrong
I was wrong in a total of four seats (85% success rate). Not bad for my first projection, especially considering my limited knowledge of local races. And it was that limited knowledge that hurt me in the end. Here are the four seats I picked the wrong winner in:

Belfast-Murray River
It seems odd that the Tories would lose a seat I predicted despite doing better than my expectations overall, but they did it here. Incumbent Charlie McGeoghegan was able to hold on to his seat in a close rematch of the 2007 by-election against Darlene Compton. Only 8 votes separated the two candidates. I wasn't too far off though, as I did predict a close race. In total I was only an average of 2% off the marks of the four parties.

Souris-Elmira
Just 210 votes separated the Liberals and Tories here in 2007, but with Liberal incumbent Allan Campbell running again, I thought he would be able to hold on. He wasn't as Tory candidate Colin LaVie won by 30 votes in a race that went back and forth all night. I didn't predict that close of a race (I had Campbell winning by 7%), but I wasn't that far off, being an average of 4% off for each party.

Stratford-Kinlock
The biggest surprise for me on election night was in this riding, deep in the heart of Queens County. My general assumption was that the Liberals would improve in Queens, but it actually did not. The race in 2007 was close, when Liberal Cynthia Dunsford won by just 81 votes. However, the 2011 election was not even close. Tory candidate James Aylward won by nearly 800 votes over Dunsford. I predicted a 7 point Liberal victory, but what happened was a 22% Tory victory. I was off an average of 7% here. While I nailed the small NDP and Green votes, I was off by much more for the Liberals and Tories.

Tignish-Palmer Road
The Tories were able to win on seat in Prince County, however it was not in Alberton-Roseville like I expected. Instead, it was in the more Liberal leaning district of Tignish-Palmer Road. The Liberals won here by 300 votes in 2007, but it was perhaps the strength of Local Conservative MP Gail Shea that made this riding blue this time around. Shea represented Tignish as an MLA before losing in 2007 and going on to become a Conservative MP. Her strength probably won this riding for the Tories, and their candidate Hal Perry. It was very close though, Perry won by just 33 votes. I was off by an average of 3% for each party here. 


Swing maps
Liberal swing (2007-2011)
 
Progressive Conservative swing (2007-2011)
As you can see from these two maps, it's a very bad idea to assume uniform swings in Prince Edward Island, where the local candidate matters quite a lot. Especially in this election, where there was little difference in the overall share of the vote from last time, local candidates made more of an impact as to how each riding swung. From looking at these maps, there's not many noticeable patterns. There are red and green ridings for both the Tories and the Liberals in all the regions.

Monday, October 3, 2011

Prince Edward Island 2011 election final prediction

Click to enlarge. Outline by S. Smith.

Prince Edward goes to the polls today, and so it's time for my final projection for the province. There have been few polls of the province during the campaign. The most recent one was released on Thursday, and so that will be what my projection will be based on.

The poll, conducted by Corporate Research Associates was quite large for PEI standards, with 700 respondents. Unfortunately, unlike the poll before it, I have not been able to find any regional numbers, so I will have to make some guesses on that front.

The polls shows that the Tories are up 5 points to 36%, while the Liberals are down 6 points to 53%, the same mark they got in the 2007 election. The NDP and the Greens are now tied with 5% each. This increase for the Tories means that some seats are now in play for them. My guess is that much of this gain occurred in Prince and Kings counties. Kings is the only place where the Tories won seats last time. However, it's possible with the current numbers to win in Prince County. Alberton-Roseville was close last time, and if the Liberals are down in Prince like I think they might be, that particular riding is in play. However, I could be way off base.

Let's look at my projections:

Projections
Riding
Lib
PC
NDP
Grn
Oth
Projected winner
Alberton-Roseville
48
46
-
5
1
Pat Murphy
Belfast-Murray River
44
49
-
6
1
Darlene Compton
Borden-Kinkora
62
28
-
10
-
George Webster
Charlottetown-Brighton
64
21
6
9
-
Robert Ghiz
Charlottetown-Lewis Point
63
28
5
4
-
Kathleen Casey
Charlottetown-Parkdale
62
26
8
4
-
Doug Currie
Charlottetown-Sherwood
61
28
6
5
-
Robert Mitchell
Charlottetown-Victoria Park
61
23
5
11
-
Richard Brown
Cornwall-Meadowbank
63
31
-
5
1
Ron MacKinley
Evangeline-Miscouche
55
38
-
6
1
Sonny Gallant
Georgetown-St. Peter's
43
46
6
4
1
Steven Myers
Kellys Cross-Cumberland
55
26
8
9
2
Valerie Docherty
Kensington-Malpeque
61
35
4
-
-
Wes Sheridan
Montague-Kilmuir
47
47
-
4
2
Allan Roach
Morell-Mermaid
40
55
-
4
1
Olive Crane
O'Leary-Inverness
60
40
-
-
-
Robert Henderson
Rustico-Emerald
71
24
-
5
-
Carolyn Bertram
Souris-Elmira
53
46
-
-
1
Allan Campbell
Stratford-Kinlock
48
41
5
6
-
Cynthia Dunsford
Summerside-St. Eleanors
52
38
5
5
-
Gerard Greenan
Summerside-Wilmot
55
39
-
5
1
Janice Sherry
Tignish-Palmer Road
53
46
-
-
1
Neil LeClair
Tracadie-Hillsborough Park
61
27
6
5
1
Buck Watts
Tyne Valley-Linkletter
56
44
-
-
-
Paula Biggar
Vernon River-Stratford
50
39
6
5
-
Alan McIsaac
West Royalty-Springvale
57
33
4
6
-
Bush Dumville
York-Oyster Bed
59
27
8
6
-
Robert Vessey

Predicting the toss ups

Alberton-Roseville:
This riding was the closest in Prince County in 2007, when Alberton mayor Pat Murphy defeated the Tory incumbent, Cletus Dunn by just 123 votes. The riding was also the Tory's best in Prince County in 1996, when the whole region shunned the Tories. It still voted Liberal that year. Dunn won both the 2000 and 2003 elections by comfortable margins. Murphy is facing Tory David Gordon, who does not appear to be a terribly strong candidate. I am fairly certain this riding will go Liberal.

Belfast-Murray River:
This seat was held by former Tory Premier Pat Binns until he resigned in 2007 after his party went down to defeat. The ensuing by-election elected a Liberal, local fisherman Charlie McGeoghegan over businesswoman Darlene Compton. The two will be duking it out again this time. McGeoghegan won the by-election by over 400 votes, a fairly comfortable margin for such small districts, but I expect he will be going down to defeat in this traditionally Tory district.

Georgetown-St. Peter's:
This riding has never voted Liberal since being created in 1996. However, it is an open seat, so it will be one to watch on election night. The Tories won by just 300 votes in 2007. The Tory candidate, Steven Myers is going against the Liberal candidate Kevin Gotell. Due to its Tory history, I do expect the PCs to keep this seat, although it will be close.

Montague-Kilmuir:
Another open seat is Montague-Kilmuir. This seat has also always elected the Tories since 1996. However, the margin was much closer in 2007, with the Tories winning by just 134 votes. I do have the current projection as being a tie, but with the Liberals slightly ahead. The Liberals are running RCMP officer Allen Roach against businessman Greg Farrell of the Tories, two competent rivals. However, I think Roach will win it. The Liberals may not have the history here, but the seat is open and, it was close last time.

Changes since the last prediction / conclusion
I have the Tories winning three seats, two more then my last projection. As mentioned, I now have them winning Georgetown-St. Peter's and Belfast-Murray River.

The PEI election will be somewhat of a snoozefest. It will be interesting to see how many seats the Tories can win, if any at all though.



Make sure to follow me on twitter this evening for live commentary. Polls close at 7pm Atlantic (6 Eastern).

Also note, the Northwest Territories will also be going to the polls tomorrow. I will be making a map of that election, but since they use consensus government, the mapping will be different.

Tuesday, September 20, 2011

Prince Edward Island projection (Sept. 20)

Click to enlarge. Outline by S. Smith
In just two weeks, Canada's smallest province, Prince Edward Island will be going to the polls. And, I have yet to write up a projection for the province which will be going to the polls on Thanksgiving, October 3. It will be the first provincial election of the Fall.

Background
The Liberal Party under Premier Robert Ghiz remains extremely popular in the province. The party's only opposition in the legislature is from the Progressive Conservative Party, led by Olive Crane. The Tories won just 4 seats in the last election in 2007, and have been polling lower than their 41% mark set then ever since. The question appears to be whether or not the Liberals can win every seat in the legislature. This has not happened since 1935. The province, being as small as it is is prone to massive swings in one direction or the other, and parties have routinely won nearly every seat in the legislature. Close elections are not the norm on the island and it has not been since 1996 since an opposition party has won more than 5 seats and it has not been since 1986 since an opposition party has won more than 10.

The most recent poll of island residents was conducted in August, and saw the Liberals with 59% (up 6 from the 2007 election) of support, 31% for the Tories (down 10%), 7% for the NDP and 3% for the Greens. The new populist “Island Party” will also be contesting the election, but was not polled. They will remain the wild card. The NDP is trying to rebound from its 4th place performance in 2007, but will be hard pressed as it is running one fewer candidate (14). The Greens, which finished third in 2007 are running 22 candidates, up four from 2007. The Island Party is running 12 candidates. There are 27 in total.

Ridings to watch





























With the Liberals polling so high, there will be few races to watch in this election. The Liberals are sure to be the strongest in Queens County, which is the central part of the Island (including Charlottetown). The August poll conducted by Corporate Research Associates poll showed that the Liberals have a 32% lead there, which is about 14% more than the last election. In Prince County, in the west, the Liberals have a 15% lead, which is about the same as the last election. This area is represented by Conservative Gail Shea in the federal House of Commons, and may be why the Tories are holding their own here. In the more conservative Kings County, in the east, the Liberals and Tories are tied. This is the only part of the province where the Tories won seats last election. If these numbers are true, then it is unlikely the Liberals will be able to sweep the province. And so, the only races to watch will be in Eastern Prince Edward Island it seems.

While they won 4 seats in the last election, the Tories only hold 2 at present. And only one incumbent is running for re-election. That is Olive Crane in Morrel-Mermaid. She won the seat by 15% in 2007, and is likely to hold on to it. Montague-Kilmuir is the only other seat the Tories presently hold. However, MLA Jim Bagnell is retiring. He only won the seat by 134 votes in 2007, and now that is vacant, it will be ripe for the picking. Georgetown-St. Peter's was vacated back in March when its MLA, Mike Currie ran for the federal Tories. He had won the seat by 9% points, and will be high target for the Liberals. And finally, the fourth seat the Tories won in 2007 was Belfast-Murray River. It was won by Tory Premier Pat Binns in 2007, but he resigned the seat later that year, only to have it filled by Liberal Charlie McGeoghegan. The Tories could pick the seat back up however, as they are polling higher than when McGeoghegan won his seat. The Tories may also have a shot at some seats in Prince County, but it is unlikely. Their best shot is Alberton-Roseville where they lost by just 123 votes.

What about the other parties? Well, the NDP has only won one seat ever on the island, in 1996. While they are polling close to where they were in 1996, with just 15 candidates, the party will likely be seen as too disorganized. If you compare the federal election to the provincial ridings however, the NDP could have a shot at Charlottetown-Victoria Park, Charlottetown-Parkdale or Charlottetown-Sherwood, where they won quite a few polls. However, the Green Party leader Sharon Labchuk is running there, and she may cut into the NDP's votes. The NDP leader, James Rodd is running in York-Oyster Bed. In the federal election, the NDP candidate did fairly well in the area, getting as high as 25% in one poll. A well run campaign could give him 20% of the vote.


Projections
Riding Lib PC NDP Grn Oth Projected winner
Alberton-Roseville 51 45 - 3 1 Pat Murphy
Belfast-Murray River 50 45 - 4 1 Charlie McGeoghegan
Borden-Kinkora 67 25 - 8 - George Webster
Charlottetown-Brighton 68 17 8 7 - Robert Ghiz
Charlottetown-Lewis Point 67 24 7 2 - Kathleen Casey
Charlottetown-Parkdale 66 22 10 2 - Doug Currie
Charlottetown-Sherwood 65 24 8 3 - Robert Mitchell
Charlottetown-Victoria Park 65 19 7 9 - Richard Brown
Cornwall-Meadowbank 68 28 - 3 1 Ron MacKinley
Evangeline-Miscouche 56 39 - 4 1 Sonny Gallant
Georgetown-St. Peter's 51 38 8 2 1 Kevin Gotell
Kellys Cross-Cumberland 59 22 10 7 2 Valerie Docherty
Kensington-Malpeque 64 30 6 - - Wes Sheridan
Montague-Kilmuir 53 43 - 2 2 Allan Roach
Morell-Mermaid
46
51 - 2 1 Olive Crane
O'Leary-Inverness 62 38 - - - Robert Henderson
Rustico-Emerald 76 21 - 3 - Carolyn Bertram
Souris-Elmira 58 41 - - 1 Allan Campbell
Stratford-Kinlock 50 39 7 4 - Cynthia Dunsford
Summerside-St. Eleanors 54 36 7 3 - Gerard Greenan
Summerside-Wilmot 57 39 - 3 1 Janice Sherry
Tignish-Palmer Road 55 44 - - 1 Neil LeClair
Tracadie-Hillsborough Park 65 23 8 3 1 Buck Watts
Tyne Valley-Linkletter 58 42 - - - Paula Biggar
Vernon River-Stratford 55 34 8 3 - Alan McIsaac
West Royalty-Springvale 61 29 6 4 - Bush Dumville
York-Oyster Bed 63 23 10 4 - Robert Vessey

Conclusion

The Liberals should easily win a massive majority. The Tories however, will probably win at least one seat (Morell-Mermaid). Whether or not they can win another is the real question. As of right now, I'd have to say no.